I have gone threw 2 sets of batteries so far. 2 optima blue tops, & 2 interstate marine batteries. I now have 2 walmart marine batteries that I used the last couple of trips last season.
I have just a basic headunit and 4 mtx 6.5 speakers with no amps so I dont understand how I drain my batteries so fast.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2
Optima batteries suck for deep cycle type uses... Your on the right track with a regular old lead acid cheapie.
I would be willing to bet the batteries are low before you even shut off the boat.

If you have a single wire POS Delco alternator you need to replace the regulator with a three wire and have an alternator of no less than 50 amps if you have electronic ignition.
IMHO you need to install an isolator and run the stereo on just one of the two batteries. This is how I roll and have never had a problem on three different boats.
GT